Automatic or manual
Most vehicles on Canadian roads today have automatic transmissions. Manuals, with a clutch pedal and gear lever, are less common but still around.
Choosing which to learn in affects how quickly you can focus on traffic skills, and which cars you will feel comfortable driving later.
By the end of this topic you can
- You can explain the difference between an automatic and a manual.
- You can select P, R, N and D safely in an automatic.
- You can hold the car still on a hill without rolling back.
- You can decide which type of car suits your learning and road test.
What you need to know and understand
- An automatic has two pedals: accelerator and brake. A manual has three: accelerator, brake and clutch.
- In an automatic, P is park, R is reverse, N is neutral and D is drive.
- Keep your foot on the brake when you move the selector out of P.
- Most automatics creep forward in D or backward in R without the accelerator.
- In a manual, you press the clutch to change gear and to stop without stalling.
- Before you book, ask your provincial licensing office whether taking the road test in an automatic affects which vehicles you may drive. Rules can differ by province and licence class.
Comparing the two
- Automatic: easier to learn, so you can focus sooner on observation and decisions.
- Automatic: less risk of stalling at intersections or on hills.
- Manual: more control in some situations, such as using lower gears on long downhill slopes.
- Manual: lets you drive a wider range of vehicles, including some older or work vehicles.
- Either way: the road test checks the same core skills of observation, control and following the rules.
Moving off safely in an automatic
- Press and hold the brake with your right foot.
- Start the engine with the selector in P.
- Keep braking and select D or R. Check the display shows the right gear.
- Check mirrors and blind spots, and signal if pulling out.
- Release the parking brake.
- Ease off the brake, then gently press the accelerator.
Hills and long slopes
On a hill in an automatic, hold the car with the footbrake rather than balancing it on the accelerator. In a manual, Ontario's handbook advises shifting to a lower gear before starting down a long, steep hill, and using the same gear going down as you would going up.
Common mistakes
- Moving the selector without your foot on the brake.
- Using your left foot on the brake in an automatic.
- Shifting into D or R while the car is still rolling the other way.
- Riding the clutch in a manual, which wears it out.
- Leaving an automatic in D when getting out of the car.
Test yourself: Automatic or manual
Answer each question, then read the explanation. Questions come in a random order each time.
Loading questions…
Go deeper
Sources: Ontario MTO Official Driver's Handbook, Stopping (ontario.ca); SGI Saskatchewan Driver's Handbook, Automatic transmission vehicles and Low speed skills (sgi.sk.ca). Independent guide, not affiliated with any licensing agency. Always check the latest official rules with your province or territory.